Astronomy Colloquia: 2016
DateTalk TitleSpeaker
January 13, 2016New Frontiers in Simulating Black Hole Accretion and JetsAlexander (Sasha) Tchekhovskoy, UC Berkeley
January 27, 2016The Universe's most extreme star-forming galaxiesCaitlin Casey, University of Texas at Austin
February 10, 2016IceCube: The Discovery of High-Energy Cosmic NeutrinosFrancis Halzen, University of Wisconsin, Madison
February 24, 2016Two studies in planetary dynamics: (i) Impact seasons on Mars, (ii) The mass function of planets in the GalaxyRenu Malhotra, University of Arizona
March 9, 2016Stellar rotation and exoplanets obliquityTsevi Mazeh, Tel Aviv University
April 6, 2016Global Radiation MHD Simulations of Black Hole Accretion DisksJames Stone, Princeton University
April 20, 2016The Dynamic Last Years in the Lives of Massive StarsEliot Quataert, UC Berkeley
May 4, 2016A data-driven model of starsDavid W Hogg, New York University
May 18, 2016The next frontier of Massive Galaxies and Quasars at the Cosmic DawnTiziana Di Matteo, Carnegie Mellon University
May 25, 2016A single prolific r-process event preserved in an ultra-faint dwarf galaxyAnna Frebel, MIT, Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research
September 28, 2016Towards the identification of Earth-like worlds with MAROON-XJacob Bean, University of Chicago
October 5, 2016Planets around Binary StarsDan Fabrycky, University of Chicago
October 19, 2016Protostellar Disks: Formation and PolarizationZhi-Yun Li, Virginia
November 2, 2016Black Hole Physics with the Event Horizon TelescopeFeryal Ozel, University of Arizona
November 16, 2016Where are we in the hunt for the core collapse supernova explosion mechanism(s)?Anthony Mezzacappa, Joint Institute for Computational Sciences, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
November 30, 2016Planet Nine from Outer SpaceKonstantin Batygin, Caltech

New Frontiers in Simulating Black Hole Accretion and Jets
January 13, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Fausto Cattaneo
Click on the image to enlarge
Alexander (Sasha) Tchekhovskoy, UC Berkeley

Black holes are responsible for a wide variety of astrophysical phenomena. They devour stars, eject relativistic jets, affect star formation and galaxy evolution, and enrich the Universe with heavy elements. In the next several years, the Event Horizon Telescope will produce resolved images of infalling gas and jets on the event horizon scale that promise to revolutionize our understanding of black hole physics. However, until recently, no first-principles models to quantitatively interpret these observations existed. I will present the first such models, the simulated spectra and images, and the constraints on the near event horizon physics coming from the comparison to the observations of the supermassive black hole at the center of our galaxy. I will then use simulations to constrain black hole physics in several other astrophysical contexts. I will finish by making connections to my future research plans.

The Universe's most extreme star-forming galaxies
January 27, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Michael D. Gladders
Click on the image to enlarge
Caitlin Casey, University of Texas at Austin

Dusty star-forming galaxies host the most intense stellar nurseries in the Universe. Their unusual characteristics (SFRs=200-2000Msun/yr) pose a unique challenge for cosmological simulations and galaxy formation theory, particularly at early times. Although rare today, they were factors of 1000 times more prevalent at z~2-5, contributing significantly to the buildup of the Universe's stellar mass and the formation of high-mass galaxies. However, an ongoing debate lingers as to their evolutionary origins at high-redshift, whether or not they are triggered by major mergers of gas-rich disk galaxies, or if they are solitary galaxies continually fed pristine gas from the intergalactic medium. Observational evidence has been mixed over recent years; some studies clearly point to chaotic kinematic histories and fast gas depletion times (~<100Myr), while other work may demonstrate secular (though active) disks can sustain high star-formation rates over long periods of time. Similarly, some works argue such extreme star-formers contribute very little to cosmic star-formation, while others find quite the opposite. Furthermore, their presence in early protoclusters, only revealed quite recently, pose intriguing questions regarding the collapse of large scale structure. I will discuss some of the latest observational programs dedicated to understanding their origins and frequency at early times, their context in the cosmic web, and future long-term observing campaigns that will reveal their relationship to `normal’ galaxies, thus teaching us valuable lessons on the physical mechanisms of galaxy growth and the collapse of large scale structure in an evolving Universe.

IceCube: The Discovery of High-Energy Cosmic Neutrinos
February 10, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM
Francis Halzen, Principal Investigator for IceCube
Click on the image to enlarge
Francis Halzen, University of Wisconsin, Madison

The IceCube project has transformed one cubic kilometer of natural Antarctic ice into a neutrino detector. The instrument detects more than 100,000 neutrinos per year in the GeV to PeV energy range. Among these, we have recently isolated a flux of high-energy cosmic neutrinos. The high cosmic neutrino flux observed indicates that a significant fraction of the radiation in the non-thermal universe, powered by compact objects from neutron stars to supermassive black holes, is generated by proton accelerators. We will discuss the IceCube instrument, the analysis of the data, and the significance of the discovery of cosmic neutrinos.

Two studies in planetary dynamics: (i) Impact seasons on Mars, (ii) The mass function of planets in the Galaxy
February 24, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Daniel Fabrycky
Click on the image to enlarge
Renu Malhotra, University of Arizona

I will present results of new calculations of the asteroidal impact flux on Mars. Mars' orbit is significantly eccentric and the planet orbits near the inner edge of the asteroid belt where the space density of asteroids has a large radial gradient. The correlated secular dynamics of Mars and the asteroids plays a significant role in modulating the impact flux on this planet. At the present epoch, this leads to a large variation -- of about a factor of three -- in the impact flux when Mars is near aphelion versus perihelion; significantly, the integrated annual impact flux is lower than would be expected in the absence of correlated secular dynamics.

The second part of the talk will describe some deductions about the planet mass function from the observational data of exoplanets and theoretical considerations of long term stability. I will describe analysis of the observational data from the Kepler space mission which indicates that planetary orbital separations have an approximately log-normal distribution. Adopting some plausible ansatzs for the dynamical stability of N-planet systems to relate orbital separations to planet masses, it appears that the planet mass function is peaked in logarithm of mass, with the most probable value of log m/M⊕ ∼ (0.6 − 1.0); a modest extrapolation indicates that Earth mass planets are about ~1000 times more common than Jupiter mass planets, and that the most common planets in the Galaxy may be of lunar-to-Mars mass.

Stellar rotation and exoplanets obliquity
March 9, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Daniel Fabrycky
Tsevi Mazeh, Tel Aviv University

Spots on the stellar rotating surface can produce periodic brightness modulation that varies with the stellar rotational period. The Kepler space mission observed more than 150,000 stars continuously for more than four years, producing unprecedentedly precise light curves. We used this data gold mine to derive the rotational periods of more than 30,000 stars.

About a thousand of the Kepler stars with derived rotational periods have been found to have planets orbiting around them. We use this sample and the derived amplitudes of the stellar modulation in particular, to infer some evidence for the star-planet obliquity - the angle between the stellar spin axis and the orbital planetary angular momentum of a planet. Previous studies found two populations of hot Jupiters - one around cool stars with orbits well-aligned with the stellar rotational axes, and the other around hot stars with isotropic distribution of obliquities, including planets with retrograde motion. We will show surprising statistical evidence that supports these findings. We will also discuss whether the amplitudes of the cool stars with planets depend on the planetary orbital periods, a dependence that might have some implications for the formation of short-period planetary formation.

Global Radiation MHD Simulations of Black Hole Accretion Disks
April 6, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Andrey V. Kravtsov
Click on the image to enlarge
James Stone, Princeton University

The inner regions of accretion flows in luminous sources such as AGN and X-ray binaries are radiation dominated. In the case of AGN, radiation and winds produced by such flows are thought to be an important feedback mechanism during galaxy formation in massive halos. I present new results from numerical studies of the magnetohydrodynamics of accretion this regime. These calculations use numerical methods based on a formal solution of the time-dependent radiation transfer equation, eliminating the need for approximate closures. We find that turbulent transport of radiation energy can be a significant contribution to the cooling rate in the disk, and this changes the global properties of the flow compared to standard slim-disk models. We describe new work to extend our calculations to full general relativity, in order to follow the dynamics in the innermost regions of the disk.

The Dynamic Last Years in the Lives of Massive Stars
April 20, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Andrey V. Kravtsov
Eliot Quataert, UC Berkeley

In the last few years of the lives of massive stars, fusion in the core of the star produces a nuclear power that greatly exceeds the Eddington luminosity. This drives vigorous convection in numerous core and shell burning phases. I describe the surprising effect that waves excited by such convection can have on the properties of massive stars in the years leading up to core collapse. Wave transport of energy into the stellar envelope can power prodigious mass loss in the last years of stellar evolution. Angular momentum transport by waves excited during shell burning phases may well determine the angular momentum of the pre-supernova core, setting the birth spins of compact objects.

A data-driven model of stars
May 4, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Andrey V. Kravtsov
Click on the image to enlarge
David W Hogg, New York University

There is a lot of knowledge built in to our physical models of stars. But there is even more information in the sum total of all the data ever taken of stars (tens of thousands of pixels of spectral data on many hundreds of thousands of targets). The Cannon (named after Annie) uses a small amount of physical modeling and a huge amount of data to build very precise, predictive, probabilistic models of stellar spectra. I show that these data-driven models can be used to obtain extremely precise measurements of stellar parameters and detailed chemical abundances, substantially more precise even than the physical models used to generate "ground truth" inputs. Indeed, we believe that The Cannon working on SDSS-APOGEE data is delivering more precise chemical abundance measurements than any previous method for the analysis of stellar spectra. These results have implications for studies of exoplanets (which I won't discuss) and the Milky Way (which I might). Work in collaboration with Melissa Ness (MPIA), Andrew R. Casey (Cambridge), Anna Y. Q. Ho (Caltech) and Hans-Walter Rix (MPIA).

The next frontier of Massive Galaxies and Quasars at the Cosmic Dawn
May 18, 2016 | ERC 401 (Note new location) | 3:30 PM | Host: Andrey V. Kravtsov
Tiziana Di Matteo, Carnegie Mellon University

I will discuss recent progress in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations of galaxy formation at unprecedented volumes and resolution. I will focus on predictions for the first quasars and their host galaxies and their contribution to reionization from the BlueTides simulation. BlueTides is a uniquely large volume and high resolution simulation of the high redshift universe: with 0.7 trillion particles in a volume half a gigaparsec on a side. This is the first simulation large enough to resolve the relevant scales relevant to the formation of the first large galaxies and quasars. These massive objects at high redshifts will be investigated with the next generation telescopes (Euclid, JWST and WFIRST).

A single prolific r-process event preserved in an ultra-faint dwarf galaxy
May 25, 2016 | ERC 401 | 3:30 PM | Host: Andrey V. Kravtsov
Click on the image to enlarge
Anna Frebel, MIT, Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research

The heaviest elements in the periodic table are synthesized through the r-process, but the astrophysical site for r-process nucleosynthesis is still unknown. The major current candidates are ordinary core-collapse supernovae and neutron star merger. Ancient, metal-poor ultra-faint dwarf galaxies contain a simple fossil record of early chemical enrichment that provides the means to study clean signatures of nucleosynthesis events, and thus, can yield unique information on the origin of these processes. Previously, extremely low levels of neutron-capture elements were found in the metal-poor stars in ultra-faint dwarf galaxies which supported supernovae as the r-process site. Based on Magellan/MIKE high-resolution spectroscopy, we have determined chemical abundances of nine stars in the recently discovered ultra-faint dwarf Reticulum II. Seven stars display extremely enhanced r-process abundances, comparable only to the most extreme r-process enhanced metal-poor stars found in the Milky Way's halo. The enhancement is also 2-3 orders of magnitude higher than that of stars in any of the other ultra-faint dwarfs. This implies the neutron-capture r-process material in Reticulum II was synthesized in a single prolific event that is incompatible with r-process yields from ordinary core-collapse supernovae but consistent with that of a neutron star merger. This would be the first signature of a neutron star merger in the early universe which holds the key to finally identifying the r-process production site. Furthermore, such a single r-process event is a uniquely stringent constraint on the metal mixing and star formation history of this ultra-faint dwarf galaxy.
(Alex Ji, Anna Frebel, Ani Chiti, Joshua Simon, 2016, Nature 531, 610,

Towards the identification of Earth-like worlds with MAROON-X
September 28, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Arieh Konigl
Click on the image to enlarge
Jacob Bean, University of Chicago

Exoplanet surveys have recently progressed to the point of discovering small, potentially terrestrial planets orbiting in circumstellar habitable zones. Assessing the true degree of habitability of these worlds requires gaining knowledge of both their bulk and atmospheric properties. In this talk I will present my group's work to make advances on these subjects. I will begin wit an overview of recent results from exoplanet atmosphere observations with an emphasis on results from major program using the Hubble and Spitzer Space Telescopes. I will then summarize the development of MAROON-X, which is a high precision radial velocity spectrograph designed to measure the masses, and thus constrain the densities of potentially Earth-like worlds. I will describe how MAROON-X will be used in conjunction with future facilities like TESS, JWST, and the GMT to make the first credible searches for habitable environments beyond our Solar System.

Planets around Binary Stars
October 5, 2016 | ERC 401 (Note new location) | 3:30 PM
Click on the image to enlarge
Dan Fabrycky, University of Chicago

Planet formation and evolution around single stars seemed hard enough. Now gas giant planets have been found orbiting binary stars, bringing new challenges and opportunities regarding the theory of planet formation and evolution. First we will review the discoveries of a dozen planets by NASA's Kepler mission, using both the transit and the timing methods. These discoveries prove that planets can tiptoe near the instability zone; the specific dynamical arrangements offers clues into migration of planets through gaseous disks. Planets seem to avoid coming near very close binaries, which is a new data point relating to the dynamical history of such binaries. That some planets went unstable is very likely, and we consider the fate of such planets as well as observational signatures.

Protostellar Disks: Formation and Polarization
October 19, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Arieh Konigl
Click on the image to enlarge
Zhi-Yun Li, Virginia

Circumstellar disks play a central role in the formation of both stars and planets, but how they form remains uncertain. Once thought to be a simple consequence of the conservation of angular momentum during the hydrodynamic collapse of molecular cloud cores, disk formation is now known to be complicated by the presence of a dynamically important magnetic field, which can strongly brake the rotation. Indeed, both analytic arguments and numerical simulations have shown that protostellar disk formation is suppressed in the ideal MHD limit for the observed level of cloud core magnetization. In the first part of the talk, I will discuss the physical reason for this so-called "magnetic braking catastrophe" in disk formation, and review possible ways to avert it, including non-ideal MHD effects, misalignment between the magnetic field and rotation axis, and turbulence. In the second part, I will discuss the millimeter polarization recently detected in the disk of the famous young stellar object HL Tau, focusing on possible contribution from scattering by large dust grains. If confirmed, the dust scattering-induced polarization would open a new window on grain growth, the crucial first step toward the formation of planetesimals and eventually planets. The field of disk polarization is poised for rapid growth in the ALMA era.

Black Hole Physics with the Event Horizon Telescope
November 2, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Arieh Konigl
Click on the image to enlarge
Feryal Ozel, University of Arizona

The Event Horizon Telescope is an experiment that is being performed on a large and ever-increasing array of radio telescopes that span the Earth from Hawaii to Chile and from the South Pole to Arizona. When data will be taken with the full array, it will image the event horizons of the supermassive black hole at the center of our Galaxy, Sagittarius A*, and the black hole at the center of M87, with an unprecedented 10 microarcssecond resolution. This will allow us to take the first ever pictures of black holes at 1.3 and 0.85 mm wavelengths and look for the shadow that is a direct evidence for a black hole predicted by the theory of General Relativity. In addition, the Event Horizon Telescope will also enable us to study the process by which black holes accrete matter and grow in mass. I will discuss the theoretical developments in simulating the properties of the black hole accretion flows and their expected images using state-of-the-art algorithms and high performance computing. Interpreting the upcoming observations within this theoretical framework will open new horizons in black hole astrophysics.

Where are we in the hunt for the core collapse supernova explosion mechanism(s)?
November 16, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Arieh Konigl
Click on the image to enlarge
Anthony Mezzacappa, Joint Institute for Computational Sciences, Oak Ridge National Laboratory

Fifty years have passed since the first simulations of core collapse supernovae were performed. Definitive simulations that assumed spherical symmetry have been completed, and laid the foundation for simulations in two spatial dimensions that assume axial symmetry and three spatial dimensions with no imposed symmetries. In the past decade, axially symmetric simulations of core collapse supernovae have matured rapidly, and three-dimensional simulations have been initiated in earnest. Progress has in fact been exponential given the derived understanding from past work and the availability of increasing computational capability. I will discuss what has been illuminated as central to the explosion mechanism to date, the current state of the community's simulation efforts, and the requirements and challenges that lie ahead in order to perform definitive three-dimensional simulations that will pin down the recipe for explosion and provide a predictive capability for all of the observables associated with core collapse supernovae. The timeliness of this progress and future push are highlighted by the recent birth of gravitational wave astronomy. The next Galactic supernova promises a wealth of information for supernova modelers and members of the gravitational wave, neutrino, and nuclear physics communities.

Planet Nine from Outer Space
November 30, 2016 | ERC 161 | 3:30 PM | Host: Arieh Konigl
Click on the image to enlarge
Konstantin Batygin, Caltech

At the outskirts of the solar system, beyond the orbit of Neptune, liesan expansive field of icy debris known as the Kuiper belt. The orbits of the individual asteroid-like bodies within the Kuiper belt trace out highly elongated elliptical paths, and require hundreds to thousands of years to complete a single revolution around the Sun. Although the majority of the Kuiper belt's dynamical structure can be understood within the framework of the known eight-planet solar system, bodies with orbitalperiods longer than about 4,000 years exhibit a peculiar orbital alignment that eludes explanation. What sculpts this alignment and how is it preserved? In this talk, I will argue that the observed clustering of Kuiperbelt orbits can be maintained by a distant, eccentric, Neptune-like planet, whose orbit lies in approximately the same plane as those of the distant Kuiper belt objects, but is anti-aligned with respect to those of the small bodies. In addition to accounting for the observed grouping of orbits, the existence of such a planet naturally explains other, seemingly unrelated dynamical features of the solar system.