KICP Friday Noon Seminars: 2016
DateTalk TitleSpeaker
January 15, 2016Helical Magnetic Fields in the CosmosAndrew Long, The University of Chicago
January 22, 2016Modified gravity inside astrophysical bodies: breaking of the Vainshtein mechanismRyo Saito, AstroParticle and Cosmology (APC) laboratory
January 29, 2016New tests of not-so-dark matterYacine Ali-Haimoud, Johns Hopkins University
February 5, 2016A 3D view of the Dark Universe: illuminating intergalactic gas at high redshift with fluorescent Lyman-alpha emissionSebastiano Cantalupo, ETH Zurich
February 12, 2016Putting the Cosmology in "21 cm Cosmology"Jonathan Pober, Brown University
February 26, 2016Quantifying discordance in the 2015 Planck CMB spectrumGraeme Addison, Johns Hopkins University
March 4, 2016Modeling the Outskirts of Galaxy ClustersCamille Avestruz, The University of Chicago
April 1, 2016Gravity at the horizon: from the cosmic dawn to ultra-large scalesMiguel Zumalacarregui, Nordic Institute for Theoretical Physics
April 8, 2016High-Scale Axions without Isocurvature from Inflationary DynamicsJohn M Kearney, Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
April 15, 2016A New Measurement of the Hubble ConstantDan Scolnic, The University of Chicago
April 22, 2016More Is Different: The Power of Multi-Probe CMB/LSS Cross-CorrelationsColin Hill, Columbia University
May 6, 2016ETHOS – From Dark Particle Physics to the Matter Distribution of the Universe and BeyondFrancis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Harvard University
May 13, 2016Resolving the Isotropic Gamma-Ray Background in the Search for Dark MatterMariangela Lisanti, Princeton University
May 20, 2016CMB Lensing Measurements, Present and FutureBlake D Sherwin, University of California, Berkeley
June 3, 2016Higgs Relaxation LeptogenesisLauren M Pearce, University of Minnesota & Valpariaso
September 30, 2016Towards precision cosmology with large scale structures: the halo model and perturbative approachesIrshad Mohammed, Fermilab
October 7, 2016Preparing for the 21cm future - lessons from the Bleien Galactic Survey projectChihway Chang, UofC
October 14, 2016Partially Acoustic Dark Matter, Interacting Dark Radiation, and Large Scale StructureYuhsin Tsai, University of Maryland
October 21, 2016SPIDER: Exploring the dawn of time from above the cloudsJeffrey P Filippini, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign
October 28, 2016ADMX (Axion Dark Matter eXperiment)Ian P Stern, University of Florida
November 4, 2016Dark Matter Radio (Hidden Photons/Axions)Arran Phipps, Stanford University
November 11, 2016Cooling and AGN heating in cool-core galaxy clustersYuan Li, University of Michigan
November 18, 2016Substantial Variation in the Stellar Halos of Spiral GalaxiesAllison Merritt, Yale University
December 9, 2016Solid-state imaging detectors for low-energy particle physicsAlvaro Chavarria, The University of Chicago

Helical Magnetic Fields in the Cosmos
January 15, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Andrew Long, The University of Chicago

It is often necessary to study cosmological phase transitions, such as inflation and thermal symmetry-breaking phenomena, through the relics that they leave behind. In this sense, the cosmological magnetic field may be a powerful probe of the early universe, which has yet to be tapped. In this talk, I will survey various topics related to primordial magnetic fields (PMFs) with helicity. We will ask: how might a PMF have been generated in the early universe, how would it have evolved in the cosmological medium, and how could it be detected today? In the first part, we discuss the interesting connection between baryogenesis and magnetogenesis, which may link the sign of the cosmological baryon asymmetry to the sign of the magnetic helicity. In the second part, we discuss the interplay between the PMF and other magnetically-active objects, such as monopoles and axions. Finally we turn to detection prospects, with an emphasis on the frontier field of magnetically-broadened TeV blazar halos.

Modified gravity inside astrophysical bodies: breaking of the Vainshtein mechanism
January 22, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Ryo Saito, AstroParticle and Cosmology (APC) laboratory

Any infrared modification of gravity, which explains the current cosmic acceleration, should not spoil the successes of general relativity in solar-system observations. In many theories of modified gravity, it is ensured by the Vainshtein mechanism that works near dense sources. Recently, it has been found that the Vainshtein mechanism can be broken inside a dense source, although not outside, in a general class of scalar-tensor theories. In this talk, after reviewing how the Vainshtein mechanism can be broken, I will discuss its impact on the density profile of a star, modeling simply it as a polytropic sphere. I also show the existence of a universal upper bound on the amplitude of this type of modification, independently of the details of the equation of state.

New tests of not-so-dark matter
January 29, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Yacine Ali-Haimoud, Johns Hopkins University

The nature of dark matter remains one of the major unsolved problems in physics, and one must leave no stone unturned when exploring empirical probes. In this talk I will discuss two different test of dark matter properties. First, I will show that dark matter interactions with standard model particles at high redshift can be probed through spectral distortions of the cosmic microwave background. In particular, I will show that upper limits from FIRAS measurements allow to constrain dark matter interactions for masses below 0.1 MeV. In the second part, I will discuss an interesting possible consequence of clumpy dark matter: flares following tidal compression events by supermassive black holes.

A 3D view of the Dark Universe: illuminating intergalactic gas at high redshift with fluorescent Lyman-alpha emission
February 5, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Combining cosmological simulation and the deepest Lyman alpha emission observations to constrain the physical properties of diffuse cosmic gas in the Dark Universe
Sebastiano Cantalupo, ETH Zurich

Gravitational collapse during the Universe's first billion years transformed a nearly homogeneous matter distribution into a network of filaments - the Cosmic Web - where galaxies form and evolve. Because most of this material is too diffuse to form stars, its study has been limited so far to absorption probes against background sources. In this talk, I will present the results of a new program to directly detect and study high-redshift cosmic gas in emission using bright quasars and galaxies as external "source of illumination’’. In particular, I will show results from ultra-deep narrow-band imaging and recent integral-field-spectroscopy as a part of the MUSE Guaranteed Time of Observation program that revealed numerous giant Lyman-alpha emitting filaments around quasars and bright galaxies. Finally, I will discuss how the unexpectedly high luminosities of the giant Lyman-alpha filaments, together with the constraints from Helium and metal extended emission, present a serious challenge for our current understanding of the Intergalactic and Circumgalactic media based on hydrodynamical cosmological simulations.

Putting the Cosmology in "21 cm Cosmology"
February 12, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Jonathan Pober, Brown University

21 cm cosmology -- the concept of using radio telescopes to observe the highly redshifted 21 cm line of neutral hydrogen on cosmological scales -- is a field on the verge of a breakthrough. The first generation of 21 cm cosmology experiments (LOFAR, MWA, and PAPER, among others) have been operating for several years, and first results at the level of design sensitivity are potentially forthcoming. In this talk, I will focus on the work needed to establish the reliability of any putative detection of the cosmological signal and the paths forward for bringing 21 cm experiments into the "precision cosmology" fold, alongside the CMB and galaxy surveys. Recent results from the MWA and PAPER will be presented, including the first limits on the z = 8.4 IGM temperature from PAPER.

Quantifying discordance in the 2015 Planck CMB spectrum
February 26, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Graeme Addison, Johns Hopkins University

In this talk I will discuss the internal consistency of the Planck 2015 cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature anisotropy power spectrum and show that tension exists between the determination of some cosmological parameters from multipoles l<1000 (roughly the scales accessible to WMAP) and l>=1000. I will show that the l>=1000 constraints are also in tension with low-redshift data sets, including Planck’s own measurement of the CMB lensing power spectrum (2.4 sigma), and the most precise determinations of the baryon acoustic oscillation scale (2.5 sigma), and Hubble constant (3.0 sigma). Finally, I will discuss some possible explanations for these disagreements.

Modeling the Outskirts of Galaxy Clusters
March 4, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Camille Avestruz, The University of Chicago

The observational study of galaxy cluster outskirts is a new territory to probe the thermodynamic and chemical structure of the X-ray emitting intracluster medium (ICM). Cluster outskirts are particularly important for modeling the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect, which is sensitive to hot electrons at all radii and has been used to detect hundreds of galaxy clusters with recent microwave cluster surveys. In cluster-based cosmology, measurements of cluster outskirts are an important avenue for estimating the cluster mass, as the outskirts are less sensitive to baryonic processes that dominate the cluster core. However, recent observations of cluster outskirts deviate from theoretical expectations, indicating that cluster outskirts are more complicated than previously thought. Computational modeling of cluster outskirts is necessary to interpret these observations. I will present cosmological simulations of galaxy cluster formation that follow the thermodynamic and chemical structures in the virialization regions of the ICM and transition to the IGM. Specifically, I will discuss how observational signatures of galaxy clusters are affected by gas flows, inhomogeneities in the ICM, and non-equilibrium physics.

Gravity at the horizon: from the cosmic dawn to ultra-large scales
April 1, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Miguel Zumalacarregui, Nordic Institute for Theoretical Physics

Recent advances in cosmology provide both the motivation and the data to probe gravity on the largest scales available to observation. I will revise the landscape of gravitational theories, focusing on modern scalar-tensor theories and their cosmological implications. Then I will present the ongoing effort to test gravity in novel regimes such as the early universe, non-linear effects and ultra-large scales. I will also introduce the hi_class code (, which is central to this program.

High-Scale Axions without Isocurvature from Inflationary Dynamics
April 8, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
John M Kearney, Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory

If the PQ-breaking scale f is larger than the inflationary Hubble scale HI, the PQ symmetry is broken during inflation. In the most straightforward models, this gives rise to a light axion field during inflation, which acquires isocurvature fluctuations. Such fluctuations are very stringently constrained by current CMB measurements---in fact, supposing the near-future observation of primordial tensor modes (i.e., a measurement of a non-zero scalar-to-tensor ratio r, indicating a high inflationary scale), these constraints would exclude simple models of QCD axion dark matter in which f is larger than HI. This is particularly problematic for the near-Planckian values of f favored by, for instance, string theory.

A variety of solutions have been proposed to ''resurrect'' high-scale axions. Many seek to leverage inflationary dynamics to modify the behavior or potential of the PQ field during inflation in order to suppress isocurvature. However, inflation and the axion potential are both very fragile, and readily disrupted by additional interactions or couplings. As such, it is important to carefully consider the viability of influencing the PQ field via inflationary dynamics; in other words, can this really be accomplished without messing up either inflation or the solution to the strong CP problem? In this talk, I'll discuss the variety of issues that can arise in these constructions, and highlight the steps one must take to build a viable model.

A New Measurement of the Hubble Constant
April 15, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Dan Scolnic, The University of Chicago

I will present a new, local, measurement by the SHOES team of the current rate of expansion (H0) of the universe from HST observations of Cepheid variables in host galaxies of Type Ia Supernovae. This measurement is a significant improvement from past measurements, and reduces many systematic uncertainties in past analyses. I will discuss the level of consistency of local measurements with measurements of H0 from the CMB.

More Is Different: The Power of Multi-Probe CMB/LSS Cross-Correlations
April 22, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Colin Hill, Columbia University

Overlapping multi-wavelength surveys allow qualitatively new cosmological constraints. In this talk, I will describe three recent such results. (1) I will present a measurement of the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel’dovich (SZ) effect with Planck, WMAP, and WISE data using a novel estimator that does not require redshift estimates for individual tracers. This measurement yields the tightest kinematic SZ-derived constraint on the low-redshift baryon fraction to date, and the result is consistent with the expectation from analyses of the primordial CMB and Big Bang nucleosynthesis. (2) I will describe an updated measurement of the thermal SZ - CMB lensing cross-correlation using the 2015 Planck full mission data. This signal constrains the mass dependence of the "hydrostatic mass bias" afflicting X-ray-based galaxy cluster mass estimates, a key systematic in cluster-based cosmological constraints. (3) I will discuss a constraint on the multiplicative shear bias in CFHTLenS data based on cross-correlations with Planck CMB lensing and CFHTLenS galaxy density maps, the first demonstration of this method on actual data. The result is consistent with a value of the shear bias that would alleviate the tension between cosmological constraints from CFHTLenS and the Planck CMB temperature power spectrum.

ETHOS – From Dark Particle Physics to the Matter Distribution of the Universe and Beyond
May 6, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Harvard University

We formulate an effective theory of structure formation (ETHOS) that enables cosmological structure formation to be computed in a vast array of microphysical model of dark matter physics. This framework maps the detailed microphysical theories of particle dark matter interactions into the physical effective parameters that shape the linear matter power spectrum and the self-interaction transfer cross section of non-relativistic dark matter. These are the input to structure formation simulations, which follow the evolution of the cosmological and galactic dark matter distributions. These effective parameters in ETHOS allow the classification of dark matter theories according to their structure formation properties rather than their intrinsic particle properties, paving the way for future simulations to span the space of viable dark matter physics relevant for structure formation.

Resolving the Isotropic Gamma-Ray Background in the Search for Dark Matter
May 13, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Mariangela Lisanti, Princeton University

The presence of all-sky, diffuse gamma-ray emission has been known for several decades, but its origins remain an open question. While astrophysical sources such as Active Galactic Nuclei and star-forming galaxies almost certainly contribute to this Isotropic Gamma-Ray Background (IGRB), dark-matter annihilation may also leave an imprint. Therefore, resolving the components of the IGRB is an important step in pushing the sensitivity to signals of dark matter annihilation, particularly in the well-motivated parameter regime for Weakly Interacting Massive Particles. In my talk, I will present a new analysis method that takes advantage of photon-count statistics to distinguish astrophysical point sources from a potential dark-matter signal. I will show results obtained by applying this technique to public data from the Fermi Large Area Telescope. Using these data-driven methods, we can start to resolve the diffuse emission from ~1--189 GeV. I will discuss the possible nature of these sources and the implications for dark matter.

CMB Lensing Measurements, Present and Future
May 20, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Blake D Sherwin, University of California, Berkeley

By directly probing the cosmic mass distribution, measurements of gravitational lensing in the CMB provide a wealth of information about neutrino masses, inflation, dark energy, and galaxy biases. In my talk, I will discuss current and future work in this new but rapidly advancing field. In particular, I will discuss current measurements of the CMB lensing power spectrum with the ACTPol experiment and future measurements with the CMB Stage-IV experiment, explaining the promise and challenges of upcoming ultra-high-precision studies of this lensing signal. Lensing is not only a signal, however, but also a source of noise that limits how much we can learn about the early universe via B-mode polarization. In my talk, I will explain why delensing - removing the lensing effect to reveal the primordial sky - is crucial for the future of CMB science and will discuss recent work in delensing theory and data analysis.

Higgs Relaxation Leptogenesis
June 3, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Lauren M Pearce, University of Minnesota & Valpariaso

The recent discovery of the Higgs boson, with a mass of 125 GeV, raises interesting possibilities for early universe cosmology. Its relatively flat potential means that it will typically acquire a large vacuum expectation value during inflation, ushering in a post-inflationary epoch of relaxation. In this talk, I will explore the possibilities for baryogenesis during this epoch.

Towards precision cosmology with large scale structures: the halo model and perturbative approaches
September 30, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Irshad Mohammed, Fermilab

The theoretical modeling of the statistical observables of the large-scale structures of the Universe, like galaxy clustering, weak lensing etc., is necessary in order to derive any constraints on the cosmological parameters. One of the most important ingredients of the theoretical model is the two-point correlation function, or its Fourier transform the matter power spectrum. I will discuss the precision in its calculations based on a modified halo model, and the systematic effects due to the baryonic processes. Further, I will also discuss the covariance matrix of the matter power spectrum and its estimators based on the halo model and the perturbation theory. We find the agreement with the simulations is at a 10% level up to k ∼ 1 h/Mpc. We show that all the connected components are dominated by the large-scale modes (k < 0.1h/Mpc), regardless of the value of the wavevectors of the covariance matrix. Finally, I will provide a prescription for how to evaluate the covariance matrix from small box simulations without the need to simulate large volumes.

Preparing for the 21cm future - lessons from the Bleien Galactic Survey project
October 7, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Chihway Chang, UofC

HI intensity mapping is emerging as a new and promising cosmological probe for both the large-scale structure and the early Universe. In preparation for the many large radio projects that are coming online, we launched the Bleien Galactic Survey project as an exercise to test new (and fun) techniques that could develop into useful tools in future surveys. I will first introduce the background science and basic setup of the experiment, and then touch upon two particularly interesting ideas - calibrating the telescope beam using drones, and RFI mitigation with start-of-the-art deep learning algorithms.

Partially Acoustic Dark Matter, Interacting Dark Radiation, and Large Scale Structure
October 14, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Yuhsin Tsai, University of Maryland

The standard paradigm of collisionless cold dark matter is in tension with measurements on large scales. In particular, the best fit values of the Hubble rate and the matter density perturbation inferred from the CMB seem inconsistent with the results from direct measurements. In this talk, I will discuss these issues and propose a solution to both problems from a dark sector that contains dark acoustic oscillations with dark fluid. Such a solution can be tested by future experiments designed to probe the CMB and large scale structure.

SPIDER: Exploring the dawn of time from above the clouds
October 21, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Jeffrey P Filippini, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign

Inflation is thought to have seeded the cosmos with a hum of primordial gravitational waves - unique messengers from the universe's earliest moments. These ripples in spacetime should have left a unique "B-mode" signature on the polarization of the cosmic microwave background. SPIDER is a powerful balloon-borne instrument designed to tease out this polarization pattern in the presence of galactic foregrounds. I will give an update from SPIDER's successful long-duration balloon flight over the Antarctic ice in January 2015, including performance estimates and the current status of the analysis, as well as a status report on payload development for SPIDER's upcoming second flight.

ADMX (Axion Dark Matter eXperiment)
October 28, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Ian P Stern, University of Florida

Nearly all astrophysical and cosmological data point convincingly to a large component of cold dark matter (CDM) in the Universe. The axion particle, first theorized as a solution to the strong charge-parity problem of quantum chromodynamics, has been established as a prominent CDM candidate. Cosmic observation and particle physics experiments have bracketed the unknown mass of CDM axions between approximately a μeV and a meV.

The Axion Dark Matter eXperiment (ADMX) is a direct-detection CDM axion search which has set limits at the KSVZ coupling of the axion to two photons for axion masses between 1.9 and 3.7 μeV. ADMX has recently begun conducting searches with an upgraded detector, which will allow for detection at even the most pessimistic couplings within this mass range. In order to expand the mass reach of the detector, ADMX is conducting extensive research and development of microwave cavity technology. Status of the experiment, current research, and projected sensitivities will be presented.

Dark Matter Radio (Hidden Photons/Axions)
November 4, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Arran Phipps, Stanford University

Determining the composition of dark matter is at the forefront of modern scientific research. There is compelling evidence for the existence of vast quantities of dark matter throughout the universe, however it has so-far eluded all direct detection efforts and its identity remains a mystery. While weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs) are a favored candidate and have been the primary focus of direct detection for several decades, there has been recent interest in searching for ultra light field dark matter. The Dark Matter Radio is a tunable superconducting high-Q lumped-element resonator (read out with SQUIDs) being built to search for sub-eV hidden photon and axion dark matter. I will discuss the motivation, detection strategy, design, and current status of the DM Radio experiment.

Cooling and AGN heating in cool-core galaxy clusters
November 11, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Yuan Li, University of Michigan

The feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGNs) is widely considered to be the major heating source in cool-core galaxy clusters, preventing a classical cooling flow where the intra-cluster medium (ICM) cools at hundreds to a thousand solar masses per year. We perform adaptive mesh simulations using Enzo including both momentum-driven AGN feedback and star formation to study the interplay between ICM cooling, AGN heating and star formation over 6.5 Gyr in an isolated cool-core cluster. We find that AGN jets globally heat up the ICM via weak shock waves and turbulence. Locally, cold clumps can cool out of the ICM due to the non-linear perturbation driven by the AGN jets. These cold clumps feed both star formation and the supermassive black hole (SMBH), triggering an AGN outburst which increases the entropy of the ICM and reduces its cooling rate. When star formation completely consumes the cold gas, leading to a brief shutoff of the AGN, the ICM quickly cools and develops multiphase gas again, followed by another cycle of star formation/AGN outburst. The simulation reproduces a wide range of observed properties and naturally explain the variety of star forming clouds observed in the center of cool-core clusters.

Substantial Variation in the Stellar Halos of Spiral Galaxies
November 18, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Allison Merritt, Yale University

The Dragonfly Telephoto Array, comprised of 48 individual Canon telephoto lenses operating together as a single telescope, is an innovative approach to low surface brightness imaging. Sub-nanometer coatings on each optical element reduce scattered light from nearby bright stars and compact galaxy centers -- typically a key obstacle for integrated light observations -- by an order of magnitude, and Dragonfly's large field of view (2 x 2.6 degrees for a single frame) provides a large-scale view of galactic stellar halos and satellite systems. Using extremely deep (>30 mag/arcsec^2) optical imaging in g and r bands from the Dragonfly Nearby Galaxies Survey (DNGS), we have characterized the stellar halos of a sample of nearby luminous galaxies. I will present measurements of the stellar halo mass fractions of an initial sample of spiral galaxies from the survey, and discuss these in the context of the assembly histories of individual galaxies.

Solid-state imaging detectors for low-energy particle physics
December 9, 2016 | ERC 401 | 12:00 PM | KICP Seminar
Alvaro Chavarria, The University of Chicago

The low noise, high spatial resolution and reliable performance of charge-coupled devices (CCDs) and complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor (CMOS) active pixel arrays have made them detectors of choice for digital imaging, from consumer electronics to state-of-the-art astronomical cameras. Although the slow time response of these devices has limited their application in high-energy particle physics, for the case of rare-event searches, where the particle interaction rate is extremely low, their properties can be fully exploited to build detectors that outperform in many aspects the traditional technologies of the field. I will present recent results from the DAMIC experiment, a low-mass dark matter search consisting of low-noise CCDs deployed in the SNOLAB laboratory. I will show how the exquisite spatial resolution of the detector allows for particle identification, and provides the unique capability to reject sequences of radioactive decay with utmost efficiency. These techniques can be extended to the field of neutrinoless double beta decay. I will present a recent proposal where we argue that a large array of amorphous Se-82 imagers based on CMOS technology could achieve the background requirements necessary to test if neutrinos are Majorana fermions even in the case of a normal hierarchy of neutrino masses.